CVE-2013-5838 Java flaw is back two-year later due to broken patch

The patch for the critical Java CVE-2013-5838 vulnerability released by Oracle in 2013 is ineffective and can be easily bypassed.

This means that attackers can exploit again the same vulnerability hacking machines running the latest versions of Java.

The CVE-2013-5838 was rated by Oracle 9.3 out of 10 because it could be exploited remotely by unauthenticated users to completely compromise a vulnerable system.

 

Security experts at the Security Explorations firm who originally discovered the flaw confirmed that the Oracle patch for the Java flaw is broken and an attacker can trigger the vulnerability to escape from the Java security sandbox.

“At the end, it’s worth to note that Issue 69 (CVE-2013-5838) was also improperly evaluated by Oracle in terms of a vulnerability impact. Oracle Critical Patch Update from Oct 2013 indicated that Issue 69 could “be exploited only through sandboxed Java Web Start applications and sandboxed Java applets” (Fig. 4).” states a report published by Security Explorations. “This is not true. We proved that Issue 69 could be successfully exploited in a server environment as well such as Google App Engine for Java [2].”

The security patch can be easily bypassed by hackers as demonstrated in a proof-of-concept exploit code released in 2013 by the researchers at Security Explorations.

“According to Oracle, the vulnerability was addressed by a backported (from JDK 8) implementation of the affected component (method handles API) in JDK 7 Update 40 from Sep 2013.”  CEO Adam Gowdiak wrote in a message sent to the Full Disclosure security mailing list.

“We however found out that Oracle patch could be trivially bypassed with the use of the following:
– four character change to our original POC code published in Oct 2013,
– a custom HTTP server enforcing “404 (Not Found)” error when requesting a given class for the first time.”

The new PoC exploit code works on the latest available versions of Java, including Java SE 7 Update 97, Java SE 8 Update 74 and Java SE 9 Early Access Build 108.

The bad news it that the CVE-2013-5838 flaw could be exploited also to target server environment.

“We verified that it could be successfully exploited in a server environment as well as in Google App Engine for Java,” added Gowdiak.

In a real attack scenario, the attackers would need to find a separate flaw that allows them to run the attack in a stealth mode bypassing the security prompts or to convince users into approving the execution of the exploit code.

There is no information regarding the way Oracle intends to solve the problem, likely by pushing out an emergency patch, otherwise we need to wait until the next quarterly Critical Patch Update, scheduled for April 19.

Pierluigi Paganini

(Security Affairs – Java, CVE-2013-5838)